Cape Cod Theater Reviews
Sorted by latest reviewed...
The Hobbit
For director Arden-Reese, the theme resonates beyond the stage. According to her, bullying might take different forms, but supporting the kids facing it is as important as ever. “In helping the dwarves and their own quest, Bilbo finds out what shines inside him — something that hadn’t shined before,” she said. But the story’s heart isn’t just in the script; it’s in the actors’ performances, their students and the energy that fills the stage. As a Cape Cod local and current associate chair at New York University’s Tisch Drama, Arden-Reese said she was thrilled to guide the cast in this process. “When a community comes together for this common purpose and people give their heart, soul and whole being to a piece, something happens. It transcends the sum of its individual parts. That’s the magic that makes theater pop,” she said. By the final curtain, Beau has faced trolls, outwitted Gollum and confronted his own “dragon.” As he steps off stage, one lesson lingers: there really is more in him than meets the eye.
The dwarfs (Celia Gaska, Quinn Martin, Shiloh Pabst, and Rebecca Reyes), led by Thorin (Stevie Carter), are happy to have Bilbo (Adam Leavitt) join the group with Gandalf (Nancy R. Flynn) advising them. First up they run into some nasty trolls, then some elves, have an encounter with the creature Gollum and his magic ring, and eventually confront Smaug the dragon. The talented duo of Anna Botsford and Jon Cornet play multiple roles beginning with Beau’s mother and father. Botsford is a troll, a goblin and an excellent Elf Queen, and Cornet is a troll, the Grand Goblin and an Elf guard. Nancy Flynn’s Granna naturally flows into the wise wizard Gandalf, and Sam Sewell’s Gollum is fantastically slithery. Seamus Sartin emotes Smaug with some cool special effects. He’s scary, but not too scary.
Southern Harmony
The ensemble of actors/singers, some of which play more than one part, is enthusiastic in its portrayal of Texan life. Marie Lemon, Ralph Prentice Danial, Dante Sterling, David Couter, Haley Jones, and Mark Fishback handle the many primarily clever songs with power and panache, and some fantastic harmonics. Set designer Christopher Ostrom has, as always, wowed the audience with his mis-en-scène—this time, a rustic Lone Star country/western interior that provides the backdrop to all the various venues and scenes. (See if you can spot the band—Nevada Lozano, Jo Miller, Robert Bekkers and Chris Cerreto—in the set’s cleverly designed pickup truck.) A shout out to costume designer Carol Sherry, who didn’t go too far over the top in creating “western” styles.
Sam Scalamoni’s skillful direction and musical staging creates a fast-moving, engaging air of folksy storytelling by an outstanding cast — both in vocals and characterization — led by Todd Buonopane’s likable, cheerful Tiede. You know he’ll become a killer, yet Buonopane wins you over with Tiede’s nerdy friendliness and quiet introspection. His disbelieving musical question, “Is This My Life?,” reflects first his good fortune as Nugent’s international travel companion, then his prison confinement. Was his murdering Nugent premeditated? Or did he snap from abuse by Nugent and in his childhood? Fogarty raises these questions, and Buonopane keeps the audience unsure of the answers.
The cast of eight, backed by four excellent onstage musicians, have terrific voices, and smooth professionalism. One standout with the right Texas accent and pizzazz is ensemble member Halley Jones as both waitress, Tammy, and Mrs. Nugent’s granddaughter. Carol Sherry’s costume changes work well, delineating the multiple characters the actors play. The musical has its moments for those who find fascination in the morbid. It’s haunting in its unresolved moral dilemmas. For those put off by the macabre, be warned away. The opening night audience found many a good laugh and was not put off by the play’s morbidity; they gave it a standing ovation.
“Southern Harmony,” though it involves tragedy, is not a grim play. In fact, there are many funny moments in it. And more importantly, it’s a showpiece of excellence in theater arts. The cast, both as actors and as singers of a far-reaching and challenging libretto, is superb. They’re an ensemble carried by the two principal characters, Bernie Tiede (Todd Buonopane) and Marjorie Nugent (Emmanuelle Zeesman, who, judging from her cast photo, is playing, very effectively, far beyond her natural years). A call out too for the tall and striking Dante Sterling as James Tyler and then defense attorney Skip Tomlinson, with his beautiful singing voice.
CIRCLE MIRROR TRANSFORMATION
With such a character-driven play, the cast needs to trust itself and develop rapport, which this group does without turning a hair. And that rapport extends to the audience. Everybody knows someone like Desham with her New Age over-confidence and perky attitude. The greatest transformation is seen in Lauren; she begins the course cynical and withdrawn, to the point of us wondering if she’s meant to be on the spectrum (she’s not: she’s a teenager, part of a demographic that often mimics autism); by the end of the six sessions she is an excellent participant, clear and focused.
The performers portray actors portraying their fellow actors in theater games designed to evoke empathy as well as self-awareness. In fact, the play is really about acting and theater as a reflective practice that is performed and received as something of a mirror. But it’s also about time and our ability to be in the moment as it happens. At one point Marty (Dersham) explains that acting is not necessarily about being in a particular play or performing a role; it’s about responding in the moment and putting aside all the other moments, past and future, as there is only the present. It’s an interesting idea, as what is “the present” is over before you can even acknowledge its existence, and so the advice of Buddhists and mindfulness trainers to “be present” is kind of a trick, something you can’t ever live up up to, as the present is the past as soon as you name it.
The director of this production is Jonathan Fielding, one of the Harbor Stage’s four founders, and the result is an immersive experience in organic storytelling: you learn about the five characters gradually, in bits and pieces, during actors’ exercises and side conversations, in their own words and from others’ points of view. It’s not always clear what is speculative and what is true. Baker, as a playwright, is known for her long silences and unrushed pacing, and Fielding builds on that. The first act is at times perplexing, at times frustrating, and the narrative is sketchy at best. The actors’ exercises are only occasionally revelatory and sometimes seem aimless. The teenage student in the class, Lauren, played pitch-perfectly by Jackie Scholl, recognizes this and openly complains about it, expressing the skepticism that some in the audience undoubtedly feel.
2025 Come From Away
The cast of 14 all perform multiple roles in the show, switching characters on stage by simply changing a hat or a jacket. This fluidity adds to the idea that we’re all part of one big melting pot or maybe that we’re all in this together—choose the metaphor that works best for you. The majority of the play is sung through with most of the songs springing up organically. The majority of the songs are sung by the entire ensemble, which adds to the feel of the show as one big group effort. One exception is “Me And The Sky,” sung with assertion by Kelli Barrett as pilot Beverly Bass. The song recounts Bass’s lifelong infatuation with flying and her raw grief in the wake of 9/11 that “the one thing I loved more than anything” has been used as a bomb.
One of the most memorable moments in the show occurs during the finale where the entire cast and orchestra comes out on stage to perform together as one. Orchestra members include musical director Lena Gabrielle (conductor, keyboard, accordion), Dan Meyers (whistles, flute, pipes), Tara Novak (fiddle), Steve Marchena (guitar), Adam McOwen (guitar, mandolin), Brian O’Neill (percussion) and Thomas Schmidt (drums, percussion). Of all the productions I have seen, I can’t recall a time where I truly felt the raw vulnerability of the characters on the stage so deeply. Bravo to Eric Rosen, Kelly Devine and the entire cast of “Come From Away” for a magnificent experience and for bringing this unforgettable story to the Cape.
Sunday In The Park With George
Other than Dot and George's story, the play explores the other subjects of the painting. There’s the “Old Lady” brilliantly recreated by Wendy Watson (she played the same role on the same stage 20 years ago) and her “Nurse.” The talented Hailey Deltano plays both the nurse and the “Mrs.” in another couple in the painting. “Mr.” is Anthony Teixeira, a Cape Rep favorite. In fact this show is stacked with Cape Rep favorites. Ari Lew is Franz, a servant, and Nell Hamilton is Frieda, the cook in the same household. Nick Nudler is Jules, an envious fellow artist, and the always delightful Holly Hansen plays Yvonne, Jule’s haughty wife. Brian Lore Evans is the muscular tattooed “Boatman” from the painting, and Ian Hamilton is Louis, the baker.
I have to list everyone here, just to acknowledge their brilliance: Przedlacki, Scampoli (and oh-my-God her voice!) and Nudler are joined by Wendy Watson, Ari Lew, Holly Hansen, Brian Lore Evans, Caroly Williams, Alex Mai Murray, Ian Hamilton, Gemma Macbride, Zoey MacBride (on opening night), Nell Hamilton, Sam Billman, Anthony Teixeira, and Haily Deltano. Just pitch- and picture-perfect, every one of them. Cape Rep has a solid and deserved reputation for attracting some of the finest vocal actors in the region, and this production in celebration of the theater’s 40th anniversary doesn’t disappoint.
2025 Anastasia
As Anastasia, Kyla Stone has a winning smile and a soaring voice that carried throughout the theater. Her character’s toughness masks an insecurity that comes with not knowing who you are. As Dmitri, Dorset talks tough but soon develops a soft spot for Anya, evident when they both talk about their difficult upbringing; both, in essence, raised themselves. Their song “My Petersburg” conveys emotion and longing. Part of his role as Dmitri is to make Anya shine; this Dorset does well.
With expert direction by Eric Rosen, the Playhouse’s current artistic director, “Anastasia” is brought to life in a magical and memorable way. The production features choreography from Emmy Award-winning Al Blackstone and phenomenal costume design by Annie J. Le. The show includes a nine-piece live orchestra and runs around two hours long with one intermission. “Anastasia” features an outstanding slate of musical numbers, including “Journey to the Past,” “Paris Holds the Key” and “Once Upon a December.” Cast in the leading role of the brave and determined Anya/Anastasia is Kyla Stone. Stone notably made history as the first African American Anya in the show’s national tour. Her solo deliveries of “In My Dreams’ and “Journey to the Past” were exquisite and heartfelt. Stone’s vocal talent was truly captivating.
Vanya And Sonia And Masha And Spike
As the self-pitying Sonia, Jennifer Cabral is simply marvelous. She makes the role completely her own, playing Sonia as a mischievous naïf with killer delivery. William Mullin, as the cranky and passive Vanya, has surprising punch, especially in his 11th-hour speech about the sad state of things. Susan Lambert, as the narcissistic Masha, is vain and vulnerable, furious and restrained in just the right measure. The three non-siblings are equally good. Hilarie Tamar, as the voodoo-practicing cleaning woman Cassandra, is a hilarious, scene-stealing revelation. Jeff Brackett attacks the role of Spike — Durang’s riff on the classic buxom blonde, with a ripped, muscled torso and bubble butt — with relish, energizing every space he’s in. And finally, Lena Moore, as the sweet and innocent neighbor Nina, finds hidden depth and awareness amid this circus of older loons.
Absurdist theater requires a gifted cast to pull it off correctly, and this production succeeds in spades. The zippy narrative and the evolution of the characters as individuals, and as a family, is driven home under the direction of David Drake, who knows how to get each actor to realize their full potential in such a beautiful way. The set design by Jenni Baldwin is built to perfection as she creates a home that is so believable as the abode of two of university professors that you can smell the pipe tobacco, old books, and regret. Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike is nothing but well-crafted fun. Don’t miss it!
There is absolutely nothing to fault here. The writing is crisp and, under David Drake’s excellent direction, the actors make the most of it, with perfect comedic timing. Durang’s use of parody and his criticism of social institutions rings true for the world of 2025, and all of that makes this sometimes-dark comedy a delight to watch. It’s the best show I’ve seen this year so far, and possibly for several other years as well.
DEATH OF A SALESMAN
The couple’s two adult sons, Biff (Alex Pollock) and Happy (Jack Aschenbach), both live at home. Biff has returned to the East after a gig working with horses in Texas. We’re introduced to the brothers in a lighthearted scene where the table functions as a bunk bed. They reminisce about girls, but the atmosphere soon grows melancholic. Pollock’s performance as Biff, a man who’s uncertain of himself, stooped, with eyes slightly downcast, cuts deep. “I’ve always made a point of not wasting my life,” he tells his brother. “And every time I come back here, I know that all I’ve done is to waste my life.” Happy, who is more outwardly successful, is still disillusioned. He feels frustrated by working in an office. The brothers talk about buying a ranch out West, but it’s just one of many unlikely fantasies running through the play — ideas the cast members spin vividly despite the spare staging.
A standout performance by Stacy Fischer as Willy’s wife, Linda, balances Willy’s depression and angst. She is the one who’s kept the family alive and functioning, and for much of the play she’s a glass-half-full sort of presence. She freaks out, however, when thinking that Willy might commit suicide; and Fischer handles her transition from “we’ll get by” to a future darker than anything they’ve experienced until that moment with fantastic realism. She knows all Willy’s secrets (borrowing money from their neighbor Charley to pay life insurance and other bills), and, after discovering the rubber hose hidden behind the heater, lives in fear that Willy will try to asphyxiate himself.
The Harbor Stage Company’s production of Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman proves that great theater doesn’t require expensive sets or extensive cast lists, just exceptional performances. The show is thoughtfully heavy, touching on themes of disillusionment and betrayal, and extremely relevant as the American dream continues to be redefined. While the cast for this tale of an American salesman losing his grip on the American Dream is made up of only four characters, this deepens the audience connection to the play by allowing for deeply intimate and powerful scenes.
Sacco & Vanzetti's Divine Comedy
All the actors, ably directed by Tim Habeger, are well up to their roles in this fine and thoughtful play. All the production values (lighting is by Ostrum himself) enhance the show.
The humor is balanced with deadly serious reminders of the reality, much of it provided by the brilliant scenic, lighting, and projection design of WHAT’s Artistic Director Christopher Ostrom. A buzzing sound and flickering of lights punctuates the scenes, a grim reminder of the electric chair. The setting is stark, the black-and-white geometrically tiled floor disappearing into its vanishing point, myriad prison bars framing the stage. And the acting is stellar.
Midsummer Dreamers
Audience members will leave stunned at their aerial feats (and rightfully so, they were spectacular), but I found myself going back in my head to Peacock’s fascinating “charade” routine. In that routine and in every aspect of the show, Peacock uses every part of her body, mind and soul to convey what she’s portraying. Nudler is a fabulous counterpart: he’s even more intense and his over-the-top-ness counters her intense but more understated performance. Not to say that she’s demure; not even close. The dynamic works. And they both are so physically strong! On the way out, I thought to myself, they must be exhausted!
It’s everything Shakespeare ever could wish: funny, bawdy, thoughtful, mischievous, wild, wonderful, joyous, intimate. As each actor alternates playing various parts from within (and without) Midsummer, the story moves at breakneck speed which can almost match the speed of the actors.
THE BOHEMIAN
Harbor Stage has once again breathed new vibrant life into a story usually relegated to college reading lists, and both Withers and Fielding are—as always—spectacularly good at pulling audience members out of their own lives and into quirky, interesting, and sometimes baffling characters. Another absolute delight.
Brenda Withers adapted, directed, and stars in The Bohemian, alongside fellow Harbor Stage Company stalwart Jonathan Fields. This piece is for those who love a bedtime story or are fans of the great novelist, Willa Cather, as The Bohemian is one of her short stories, published in 1912.
The two actors switch off bread-baking duties. In one scene, Withers, as Nils’s mother, pares fruit as family matters are discussed. “Land’s a good thing to have,” Nils says, trying to placate his mother. “Only when you stay on it,” she replies sourly.
Angels In America Part Ii: Perestroika
In this new production of Perestroika, the actors reprising their roles from Millennium Approaches have honed their performances, all of them improved. (Which is saying something: they were all splendid last year.)
Joe MacDougall accomplishes the impossible by giving full humanity to Roy Cohn, who in real life seemed soulless. In a lesser actor’s hands the character would be little more than a hissing, snarling creature. But MacDougall creates a character so fully formed that Cohn’s hideous nature and evil core isn’t something supernatural, but rather chillingly human, which makes it part of the mortal world and all the more frightening.
Drake’s direction is a large part of why this performance had audience members in tears and inspired them to give a rousing standing ovation with more shouts of “bravo!” than I think I’ve ever heard. He brings magic, freshness, and discovery to a play that is, let us not forget, three and three-quarters hours long—time that passes quickly thanks to his sense of timing. (The audience is warned about the length, with Drake quipping, “And after that… we serve breakfast!)
Every Brilliant Thing
Literally being part of the show helps you connect deeply with it. It really is more than a play; it's an experience. This lovely theater in the woods always thinks outside the box, and just when you think you’ve seen all a theater can do they surprise you with something new.
Cape Rep’s newly renovated barn provides open spaces, intimate spaces, and most of all flexible spaces; it’s easy to see why the organization has put so much effort into its restoration. Director Julie Allen Hamilton, lighting designer Susan Nicolson, sound designer Maura Hanlon, and costume designer Robin McLaughlin have created, in concert with Wheeler himself, an absolute jewel of an inaugural play. It’s hard to imagine a more perfect experience.
The Importance Of Being Earnest
This production excels. The cast — Maeve Moriarty, Keith Richard Chamberlain, Rick Sherburne, Daniel Powers, Joe Hackler, Dafydd Rees, Brynn Grambow, Hannah Reggio and Kathleen Larson Day — are perfect in their roles. But Rees steals the show. To tell you how would really be to spoil some great fun.
A unique group of nine actors do good justice to this lovely, maverick production, staying true to its classic Victorian setting of superficial obsessions, where style rules substance. These trivial pursuits, hilariously performed, showcase Wilde’s talent for sardonic wit and clever bon mots.
Almost Maine
The 18 performers in Drake’s Provincetown production never miss a beat. There isn’t a weak link among them. This level of professionalism is rare in community theater, and many in the cast do indeed live and work here. Almost, Maine sets a high bar.
What can be said about the 18 actors is that they’re all top-notch. Every one of them, whether new to the stage—as is the case with a few—or recognizable from myriad other Provincetown Theater and Outer Cape venues, felt authentic and real.
The World Goes Round
Each cast member had ample time to shine in the spotlight, as well. Holly Hansen’s “Colored Lights” was heartfelt and enchanting, and Rebecca Riley captured the audience’s hearts with both her voice and her comic timing in "Arthur in the Afternoon” and “All that Jazz.”
This is not your grandmother’s version of a “revue” or tribute “collection.” Audiences can look forward to a fast-moving, diverse and extraordinary production full of color and variety, offered by six consummate actors with a host of vocal creds.
Pickle Me Tink
Ari Lew is Hugo, the lovesick and down-on-his-luck nice guy who is under the tutelage of Captain Lewis, played by Brian Lore Evans. Lew has so mastered his comedic role that we could watch his face on a screen and still laugh. He’s that good!
As difficult as it may seem to steal a scene with this talented troupe, Holly McCarthy manages to. As Dr. Tillman, McCarthy changes her accent at the drop of a hat (or in this case, a turn of a hat). The exaggerated, ludicrous accents are amazing and so funny!
This show is completely, wonderfully, laugh-out-loud-until-you-cry perfect for this moment—and does this cast ever deliver! The story is the stuff of a hundred silent films, with Marx Brothers, Abbott and Costello sprinkled throughout, and a little I Love Lucy thrown in for good measure.
O L I V E R!
Folks at the Academy of Performing Arts regularly tackle these big musicals in their small theater and the community is the better for their efforts. Choreographer Missy Potash and orphans choreographer Sydney Peterson deserve credit for moving 50 people around the stage, not to mention having the orphans kicking legs (and not each other!) in a chorus line.
The wildly talented Denise Page, who plays Nancy, delivers the jawdropping solo performance of “As Long as He Needs Me” and believe me, it will leave you with chills.
The Fade Away Advantage By Meryl Cohn
The four-person cast is a delight. D’Arcy Dersham as Michaela and Susan Lambert as Jojo are electric as they dance around each other, dissecting their characters’ memories and expectations with spot-on emotional fervor. Janet Geist Moore as Baby is hilarious and has the distinction of being the oddball character that barges into the action precisely when she’s not wanted.
Cohn’s script is simultaneously witty and meditative, sexy and absurd. It defies our expectations more than once. Baby barges in until she’s needed — then she doesn’t come. There very well might be a ghost in the cottage, but she doesn’t mean much to anyone but Baby. Jojo and Michaela are best friends and maybe more.
This play is fantastically thought-provoking, entertaining, and a wonderful lens through which to think about what matters most in life—and death—to each of us.
Dracula
A standout performance on opening night was Macklin Devine as the certifiably crazy Renfield. Granted, this character is intense in any production about Dracula, but Devine was simply divine as the fly-eating lunatic. The strong ensemble of Dracula’s ghouls and household staff need a mention too. They were Anna Botsford, Zendon Donoho, Nansea R. Flynn and Violet Hellstrom.
Amelia F. Burbine plays Lucy with a wonderfully sweet vulnerability then instantly switches her into a woman with lusty appetites.
Barefoot In The Park
Simon’s Tony-nominated play is peppered with funny lines, one of the funniest delivered by Paul responding to Corie’s threat to get a guard dog: ‘She’d take him for his first walk, he’d see these stairs and go right for her throat.”
Chatham Drama Guild has hit one out of the titular park with this production. Every single member of the cast makes the most of their time onstage, and the opening night crowd responded enthusiastically, filling the theater with laughter. If you are looking for a romantic comedy in which every performer hits their mark every time, you simply can’t do better than this cast. They absolutely shine.
The Heart Sellers
It’s love at first sight when Regullano bounces onto the stage, laundry on the couch, and a yapper she can’t contain. She’s a delight to watch and to hear, and her jumbled excitement and pain flow out of her like a tiny Niagara Falls. Kim is the perfect listener, expressing herself the best she can while being a calming presence.
The Heart Sellers offers the kind of humor that’s enjoyed in the moment but causes later profound reflection—the best kind, to my mind. The production timing is tight and the silences—there are several—are woven in expertly and subtly. This is a story that will stay with you long after the final curtain.
And Then There Were None
The entire cast brought their best performances, transforming the Academy stage into a spooky and mysterious setting that only Dame Christie could conjure.
Bragan Thomas is delightfully pompous as the butler Rogers, Roderick is fun as the man-about-town Marston, Bob Shire has a commanding presence as the judge Sir Lawrence Wargrave and Erica Morris is endearing as the young secretary Vera.
Liberty Talks!
It is of course Curry who is the star, present in every scene, wise-cracking, showing us what might be going on behind the façade of easy-to-espouse yet difficult-to-live concepts. He is wickedly funny, sexy and absurd by turns, with a strong voice that is startlingly human (smoking a joint, drinking bourbon, and popping pills… “I take them for my back, okay?” she hisses. “You try holding up that torch!”).
The show is frenetic but fun and packed with fascinating historical facts. Libby (Brandon Curry) sets the audience straight from the get-go. “Honey, where is your suspension of disbelief?” she asks.
The comedic exhaustion the Statue of Liberty feels as she has to handle the voices in her head as to who she is, defined by everybody from an equally chatty statue of Sojourner Truth to a Texas school teacher, give this production directed by Janice J. Goldberg, a roller coaster style pacing with absurdity and sentimentality offering a compelling interpretation of these confusing times that are filled with hope and fear.
I was reminded of Wicked while watching Liberty Talks: both take an iconic figure and peek behind a glossy façade to find the real story of how they came to be, full of contradictions and ironies. There is much that is disillusioning in Rojas’s play, just as there is in the American Dream. The land of the free is a promise that is often kept and often broken. It’s more of an ongoing struggle, and that’s exactly what Liberty Talks captures on a very personal level.
2024 The 39 Steps
More than a spy story injected with humor, “The 39 Steps” is a tour de force of not only unforgettable performances but ingenious stagecraft, brilliant sound and lighting design and clever, sleight-of-hand costume designs.
Kareem Bandealy is the hero, Richard Hannay, with a full gamut of physical comedy skills on display. Lori Vega plays a trio of three different women who entrance and entangle Hannay: the glittery femme fatale; a farmer’s wife who, with the aid of a Bible, helps Hannay escape the outraged farmer; and a woman he keeps crossing paths with and can’t help becoming attached to, as you’ll see.
W E S T M I N S T E R
The dynamics between the characters demonstrates a push-pull relationship, each actor playing off the other. Westminster is very much a Withers play. It is funny and insightful, and it escalates delightfully to an over-the-top crescendo clearly calling out the prejudices and blind-spots human beings have about one another and the difficulty we have putting our money where our mouths are.
The way this quartet works together, suspension of disbelief is automatic. Westminster is irresistibly entertaining.
Withers is Pia, and Stacy Fischer is Krysten, who together share wordplay and telling body language when questions and answers balloon into seemingly unsolvable quagmires. They are excellent in their rapid-fire dialogue, clearly illustrating how Pia fancies herself mature and genteel and Krysten portrays an intelligent airhead with a big secret to hide.
Westminster caps a stellar season at the Harbor Stage Company. This production isn’t just excellent, it does something that goes beyond the stage, diving deep into what priorities we create in our lives and whether those priorities can accommodate the people we used to be—and those who knew us then. How do we handle the dangers inherent in emotional honesty? Can any of us survive it? I always want to fall in love with the plays I attend, and I’m head-over-heels for this one. There are echoes of Ionesco and a definite absurdist flavor to The Dog as both symbol and manifestation, some thoughtful characterizations, and a few surprises along the way. Go see it!
Summer, 1976
Annie Miesels astounds. It is her multifaceted interpretation of the flakey yet incredibly sharp Alice that brings a jaunty levity to this incredibly profound narrative. Jennifer Van Dyck, playing Diana, gives a performance both humorous and emotionally impactful.
Diana is acerbic and contrary, she hates kids, but she loves kids. She is turned on by the smell of paint. She has some very funny lines. We never really find her backstory. Alice is more openly endearing, finding joy as years progress in teaching middle schoolers, in her grandkids, and her daughter’s success, while Diana’s daughter is troubled, perhaps a victim of her mother’s inability to bond with other human beings.
In this relatable and warm WHAT production, the actresses and Walker make these characters two women you’re glad to know.
The acting is simply superb. Meisels and Van Dyck show their differences in every way: their physicality, their gestures, their voices, their expressions. They make the audience believe in their hesitation to embrace friendship and their tentative reliance on it.
Annie Meisels playing naïve housewife Alice and her artist and fierce single-mom neighbor, Diana, played by Jennifer Van Dyck, are powerhouses. Meisels is sweet in a floral dress while the harder-edged Van Dyck wears silk and denim. Each is enthralled and confused by the other, but the development of the characters and the plot is seamless and so real, it’s easy to become the proverbial fly on the wall and sit in rapt attention for the 90-minute (no intermission) show.
2024 Waitress
“Waitress” contains every ingredient necessary for a perfect production: it is relatable, the songs are memorable and the entire cast is top notch. You’ll be playing the soundtrack the whole way home and dreaming of homemade pies. The echoing, longing sounds of “sugar, butter, flour” will leave audiences craving more “Waitress” long after the musical ends.
The dynamic between Jenna and the diner’s owner Joe (John Shuman) is heart-warming and his song, “Take It From An Old Man” is a reminder of how fast the years pass.
The Pirates Of Penzance
Standouts on opening night were the indomitable, eye-rolling Holly Hansen, Hailey Deltano’s show-stopping vocals, the dynamic Mo O’Neill and Alex Murray in the ensemble, and of course Jared Hagen’s over-the-top Major-General. But seriously, everyone was incredible. This entire group sings, dances and emotes constantly with such joyful, enthusiastic energy.
The singing is masterful, and Holly Hansen as Ruth sets the bar that is then challenged by Hailey Deltano as Edith. Then, in walks Juliet Pearson as Mabel who sounds like a coloratura soprano singing high notes with ease whether she is wrapped in the arms of Aamar-Malik Culbreth as Frederic or getting drunk while slouching in a beach chair. Culbreth and Pearson share a beautiful duet in “Stay, Frederic, Stay!” and Jared Hagan delights with “I Am The Very Model Of A Modern Major-General.”
It would be easy to call out every single person who worked on this production; it’s as near perfection as any theater, anywhere, can get. If you haven’t seen Gilbert & Sullivan, come try it out. If you’ve already seen Gilbert & Sullivan—trust me, you haven’t seen it like this.
I Have A Song To Sing, O! A Gilbert & Sullivan Revue
Some of the standout moments of “I Have a Song to Sing, O!” include a pleading “Spurn Not the Nobly Born” by the excellent Joseph So, a breathless whirl of “I Am the Very Model” sung by Robert Grady and the chorus, a gorgeous rendition of “Poor Wandering One” by the gifted Laura Barabe, a touching “My Lord, A Supplicant at Your Feet” performed by Pam Banas, and a rousing rendition of “He Is an Englishman” by Scott Hamilton and the chorus. The members of the entire cast put their team differences aside and join together in the final spirited number from “Yeoman Of The Guard,” “I Have a Song to Sing, O!”
Chatham Drama Guild touts a multitalented cast and crew that shines brightest during solo numbers. Alex Luchessi’s deep vibrato captivates the audience in “Oh Is There Not One Maiden Breast'' and “On a Tree by a River,” playing a crucial character in both “Mikado” and “Pirates of Penzance.” Joseph So offers an earnest, whimsical rendition of “Spurn Not the Nobly Born '' while dressed in shimmering fairy attire. Finally, standout Laura Barabe stuns while performing “Poor Wandering One” and “Fair Moon, To Thee I Sing,” demonstrating incredible breath control and an impressive range.
Heathers The Musical
This ‘80s girl will guarantee you don’t have to know the movie “Heathers” by heart or at all to love the musical. Better motor and get your tickets now — this one is sure to sell out fast.
The leads, Ohlson and Kuehne, set the tone with deliveries that are strong and stirring. Kuehne, as the moody and mysterious outsider J.D. weaves a sense of spine-chilling emotion into every song. And Kimberly Matthews, as Ms. Fleming and Veronica’s mom, has the audience in her hand in the number “Shine a Light.”
Robin Hood
Actor TJ O’Leary dominates the stage, playing this insufferable oaf of a royal with a perfect mix of immaturity and abrasiveness, capturing the infuriating and dangerous implications of insecurity with a hilarious jaunt.
It’s not only amusing but especially fun for children who have not been to an outdoor production. This immersive experience ensures that cast members are everywhere in the outdoor vicinity, making the audience feel like they are part of the story.
The Rocky Horror Show
...the real standouts of this thoroughly synchronized ensemble are the corruptible innocents, Brad and Janet, played by a real-life couple, Zack Johnson and Madison Mayer. Both of them are a bit more zaftig than the Brads and Janets I’ve previously seen (such as Barry Bostwick and Susan Sarandon in the movie), but they make it work in their favor.
It’s a summer for cult classics on the Cape, and for sheer fun it’s hard to beat Rocky Horror. You won’t be allowed to fling rice, but you will be transported and entertained, treated to a past favorite that is magic escapism for 2024.
Zack Johnson has a lovely voice when he sings his solos “Once in a While,” and “Damnit Janet.” He and Mayer are real-life partners whose natural affinity adds heft to the otherwise goofy plot. Mayer’s all charming innocence as she sings and struts her way to a new self realization and is aided by a cast of accomplished artists.
For all the frivolity and funk that is The Rocky Horror Show, it is first and foremost a rock-and-roll floor show. And the cast rises to the occasion, especially Zack Johnson and Madison Mayer as Brad Majors and Janet Weiss, who each give powerhouse performances as the soon-to-be corrupted innocent couple.
My Dinner With André
Being able to constantly watch Fielding’s reactions — rather than having occasional cuts to Wally in the film — also adds comedy and depth. Fielding uses body language, furrowed brows, and trying-to-be-patient expressions to indicate his skepticism and attempts to understand, sometimes pushing into a “What the heck are you talking about?” stare that gets laughs.
Fielding’s take on the less verbal, more philosophical Wally is completely believable. His ability to create a new character without sacrificing everything that made the film’s many fans love Wally deserves an extra scoop of dessert. And Robin Bloodworth’s mostly silent role as The Waiter contributes greatly to the sense that you’re eavesdropping on a real conversation. His very subtle disdain for Wally is proof that there are no small parts.
It’s daring of course to be the first one to do anything; adapting a movie—that already has cult status—for the stage is super-daring, with the inevitable comparisons it invites; but Harbor Stage owns this story. Kropf captures the essence of a kind of artist who stays on the highwire not because he’s afraid of falling but because it’s the only place he can find meaning; Fielding is the artist who wants his work to fit into the overall picture of a life where process is more important than success. And both Kropf and Fielding absolutely shine.
The performance is riveting. My companion took her “assist the reviewer” job seriously and watched the cult 1981 movie by the same name.
Little Shop Of Horrors
Alex Valentine is the booming, cursing voice of Audrey II, demanding sacrificial meals from Seymour—“Must be blood, must be fresh”—and pointing out the not-so-obvious: “a lotta folks deserve to die.”
Kotska as Seymour strikes just the right balance as he works to win his love Audrey and prevent her namesake from eating the people he cares about.
2024 Beautiful
Knitel delivers an absolute standout performance as King. She belts out each King classic with powerful clarity, while ensuring her every movement and word is charged with King’s charisma and humor. Over two hours and 20 minutes, the audience witnesses Knitel’s King transform from a gawky teen into a confident woman, sure of her voice and the power it holds.
If the buzz and camaraderie during intermission at last Saturday’s matinée of Beautiful: The Carole King Musical was an indication, audience members were having “one fine day” at The Cape Playhouse.
Seating the full house was somewhat chaotic with patrons entering through multiple doors and clogging the aisles as ushers tried to help find seats. However I would navigate that traffic jam again in a New York minute to take in this bright, lovely show.
Reefer Madness
Everyone gives fabulously engaging performances, with stand-outs being Jody O’Neil as the Lecturer, the Greek chorus of the play, Brittany Rolfs as Mae, the reefer den matron with a heart of gold, Maranda Rossi as Mary Lane, the sweet and innocent all-American girl corrupted by the Devil’s cabbage, and Gabriel Graetz in multiple roles, including a hysterical, yet wonderfully disturbing turn as a baby neglected by his dope fiend mother. As a company, the entire cast brings their A-game.
This dusted off Reefer Madness turns out to be a timely show, and in the capable hands of WHAT, also a medical-grade escape into laughter. Comedy is an indispensable tool for confronting the incomprehensible and also for processing frustration and anger.
It’s not the plot that makes Reefer Madness so much fun, of course; it’s the lovely wackiness of it all. Eras come and go with some abandon and little logic—from dancing the Charleston to the evils of jazz, from bobby socks and soda jerks to slinky lingerie and bobbed coiffures, it’s hard to see exactly when it’s supposed to take place, which adds to the silliness of it all.
Definitely go to the show for the whole package – it’s well worth the ticket price at any amount - but Graetz’s moment is the pinnacle. I wanted him to sing it twice.
Hedwig And The Angry Inch
Hedwig and Yitzhak, respectively, and who’s performances are so dynamic it gives the illusion that they jut out into the theater, as if we’re wearing 3-D glasses. And their voices register on the Richter scale.
The two leads, Diem and Moran, are vocal powerhouses, and their performances are imbued with multiple shades of suffering and self-awareness. They are a revelatory pair, both of them actor friends in the Michigan theater scene. And the physical production is a queer-punk kaleidoscope of images, props, and music.
“Hedwig and The Angry Inch” is just as much a musical as it is a stand-up comedy. Diem and Moran are quick-witted, tastefully raunchy and unapologetically blunt; this two-man show will have audiences cackling just as much as they are crying.
The Drowsy Chaperone
It’s nonstop fun action and hilarity, along with outstanding singing and dancing. There’s a tap dance routine, acrobatics and even roller skating. Don’t miss this show!
It does what a musical is supposed to do: it takes you to another world. And it gives you a little tune to carry in your head. A little something to help you escape from the dreary horrors of the real world. A little something for when you’re feeling blue.