Cape Cod Theater Info

Your Ultimate Guide to Cape Cod Theater:
Current Shows, Genres, and Venues

Follow Us on Instagram! @CapeCodTheater.Info

📬 Subscribe for Weekly Shows in Your Inbox!

Unreconciled poster

Unreconciled

At Cotuit Center for the Arts

Unreconciled is based on the true story of an adolescent actor cast as Jesus in a school play directed by a parish priest. Set in a working class suburb of Philadelphia, this solo-show chronicles a survivor’s journey as he confronts his past, navigates a victims’ reparations program set up by the Catholic Church, and discovers the courage to use his voice. This 80-minute piece is a poignant and at times humorous exploration of family, place, and the meaning of reconciliation.

Buy Tickets

Reviews for Unreconciled

Unreconciled

Cotuit Center for the Arts

Oct 9, 2025·The Enterprise

The use of posture, voice, hand gestures and more differentiates Sefton’s characters without need for props or costumes. Sefton even plays the voice in his head, sparring with his own scolding altar ego. Then there’s the stamina required to be alone on stage for 80 minutes telling your own, excruciatingly personal story. Sefton holds his audience spellbound. The play slides between the past and the distant past, between the pageant, family dinners which occasionally included Father Tom, meetings with church lawyers and Sefton’s struggle to come to terms with his own story. In a play that has many uncomfortable and upsetting moments, perhaps the most heartbreaking is when Sefton recalls that all the kids in the play knew what was happening; even if they couldn’t name it, “we were not fooled.” “No one called it abuse, so I don’t either.” The adults who could have prevented it either didn’t know or were in denial.

— Joanne Briana-Gartner Source

Full List of Shows

Missing a Show or Theater?

Let Us Know!

We're dedicated to providing the most comprehensive listings of Cape Cod theater shows, but we can't do it without your help. If you notice a show or theater that's not listed on our site, we want to hear from you!

(dates, times, genres, and venue information)

We'll make sure to add it to our listings right away. Your input helps us keep the Cape Cod theater community informed and connected. Thank you for helping us make our site the go-to resource for all things theater on the Cape!